Tharoor’s Message To The Prime Minister
As Prime Minister Narendra Modi marked his 75th birthday, greetings poured in from across the political spectrum. Among the many wishes, one stood out for its political implications: Congress MP Shashi Tharoor’s message. Posting on social media platform X, Tharoor wrote, “Wishing Prime Minister @narendramodi a very happy birthday. May the year ahead be filled with good health, happiness, and continued success in the service of the nation.”
The gesture, simple and polite in tone, nevertheless sparked conversations, particularly because Tharoor has faced criticism from within his own party for previous remarks perceived as being complimentary towards the Prime Minister.
Past Remarks That Stirred Controversy
This is not the first time Shashi Tharoor’s words about Narendra Modi have raised eyebrows. Earlier this year, he had described Modi as “undoubtedly the most dominant political figure in the country,” acknowledging the Prime Minister’s enduring personal appeal across large sections of the electorate.
While Tharoor clarified that his observations were about political reality rather than ideological support, several Congress leaders questioned the necessity of such statements, particularly in the backdrop of upcoming electoral battles. His commentary, however nuanced, was interpreted by some as politically inconvenient for a party that has built its campaigns around sharp criticism of the Modi government.
Reactions Within The Congress
The Congress party has traditionally maintained a combative stance against the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and Prime Minister Modi personally. Tharoor’s consistent emphasis on civility, and his willingness to acknowledge Modi’s political strengths, has therefore often put him at odds with colleagues.
Party insiders suggest that gestures like birthday greetings, while seemingly routine, are closely scrutinised for their larger political messaging. In a climate where symbolism carries significant weight, Tharoor’s latest wish is being dissected as much for timing as for intent.
Clarifications On Civility Versus Endorsement
Tharoor has repeatedly argued that respecting political opponents does not mean endorsing their policies. He has said that in a democracy, leaders can disagree vehemently on governance while still maintaining personal decency. In fact, Tharoor believes that courtesy in political discourse strengthens democratic traditions rather than weakening opposition.
His defence underscores a larger debate in Indian politics: should civility between rivals be seen as a dilution of opposition, or as a healthy sign of political maturity?
Earlier Controversy Over Diplomatic Delegation
Tharoor’s standing within the Congress also came under the spotlight earlier this year when the government named him to head an all-party parliamentary delegation to the United States and other countries under Operation Sindoor, following the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack. While the Congress had not proposed his name, Tharoor accepted the responsibility. The decision was seen by some as him stepping beyond party lines, further fuelling speculation about his rapport with the ruling dispensation.
Modi’s 75th Birthday Celebrations
Meanwhile, Modi’s 75th birthday was marked by large-scale celebrations organised by the BJP across the country. Welfare initiatives, health camps, and community service programmes were held to honour the milestone. Party leaders highlighted the Prime Minister’s leadership and vision, presenting the day not just as a personal celebration but also as a reaffirmation of their political commitment.
The day also saw greetings from leaders across ideological divides. Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan, known for his sharp differences with the BJP, posted on X: “Warm birthday wishes to Hon’ble PM @narendramodi. Wishing you good health and happiness.” Such cross-party wishes added to the atmosphere of civility that contrasted with the usual political sparring.
Political Symbolism Ahead Of Elections
With general elections and key state polls on the horizon, every public message acquires political weight. Tharoor’s birthday wish, while courteous, may once again be interpreted as a reminder of his independent political style. Whether it adds to his image as a statesman-like figure or fuels further friction within Congress remains to be seen.
Ultimately, the incident highlights how even routine gestures can become politically charged in India’s vibrant democracy. Tharoor’s balancing act—acknowledging political realities while staying committed to opposition—continues to make him a figure closely watched by both supporters and critics.
